Inspired by Gilad’s great summary on the Cloud Programming model, I try to summarize the difference that I observe between the traditional SaaS model and the “cloud-enabled SaaS model”. Although cloud providers advocates zero effort is need to migrate existing applications into the cloud, it is my belief that this “strict-port” approach doesn’t fully exploit the full power of cloud computing. There are a number of characteristic that cloud is different from traditional data center environment, application which design along these characteristic will take more advantages from the cloud.
I believe a Cloud-enabled-Application should have the following characteristic in its fundamental design.
Latency Awareness
Traditional SaaS App typically run within a single data center and assume low latency among server components. Now in the cloud environment that span many distant geographic locations, but the assumption of low latency cannot hold any more. We need to be “smarter” when choosing where to deploy to avoid the situation of putting frequently communicating components between far-distant locations. “Cloud-enabled SaaS app” need to be aware of latency difference and built in self-configuring and self-tuning mechanism to cope with that.
Cost Awareness
Traditional SaaS app typically run on already purposed hardware where utilization efficiency is not a concern. Now with the “pay as you go” model, application need to pay more attention to its usage pattern and efficiency of underlying resources because it will affect the operation cost. Cloud-enabled SaaS application need to understand the cost model of different resources utilization (such as CPU cost may be very different from Bandwidth cost) and adjust their usage strategy to minimize the operation cost.
Security Awareness
Traditional SaaS app typically run on a fully trusted data center based on perimeter security. But in the Hybrid cloud model, the perimeter being drawn is very different now. Application need to carefully select where to store its data such that sensitivity will not be leaking. This involve careful determination of storage provider or use encryption for protection.
Capitalize on Elasticity
Traditional SaaS App is not used to large-scale growth / shrink of compute resources and typically haven’t designed well to handle how data get distributed to newly joined machines (in a growth scenario) or redistributed among remaining machines (in a shrink scenario). This ends up having a very inefficient use of network bandwidth and results in high cost and low performance. More sophisticated data distribution protocol that align with the growth and shrink dimension is needed for “Cloud-enabled SaaS app”
Found this article cloud“>here
8 Responses to Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS
William Toll
October 30th, 2009 at 12:57 pm
Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS http://bit.ly/F2quQ
Stephen McCarron
October 30th, 2009 at 12:59 pm
Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS http://bit.ly/F2quQ (via @utollwi). Important distinction!
the WHIR
October 30th, 2009 at 1:28 pm
RT @utollwi: Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS http://bit.ly/F2quQ
Tweets that mention Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS | SaaSBuzz.com - The SaaS Community -- Topsy.com
October 30th, 2009 at 1:28 pm
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by the WHIR and William Toll, Stephen McCarron. Stephen McCarron said: Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS http://bit.ly/F2quQ (via @utollwi). Important distinction! [...]
Sam Johnston
October 31st, 2009 at 4:57 am
Whether we like it or not, cloud computing to the overwhelming majority means “Internet-based computing”. What, pray tell, is “SaaS” if it’s not Internet-based?
A better title for this article would have been “SaaS best practices. Trying to create differentiation where there is none is just plain confusing.
Otherwise nice points.
Sam
Sam Johnston
October 31st, 2009 at 4:58 am
RT @utollwi: Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS http://bit.ly/F2quQ <- what? no. try "SaaS best practices" – see comment.
Sam Johnston
October 31st, 2009 at 4:59 am
RT @smccarron: Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS http://bit.ly/F2quQ (via @utollwi). Important distinction! <- ohrly?
uberVU - social comments
October 31st, 2009 at 5:08 am
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by utollwi: Traditional SaaS vs Cloud Enabled SaaS http://bit.ly/F2quQ...